The New Montinian Church

The New Montinian Church, written by Rev. Joaquin Saenz y Arriaga, PhD, is a comprehensive critique of the changes introduced by Vatican II. Published in 1971, the book argues that the Council’s reforms have led to a fundamental transformation of the Catholic Church, deviating from its traditional teachings and practices.

The author contends that Vatican II’s emphasis on “equality, liberty, and fraternity” has introduced Judaeo-Masonic principles, undermining the Church’s authority and doctrine.

He criticizes the Council’s ecumenical efforts, arguing that they have compromised Catholic distinctiveness and led to a watering down of dogma.

Saenz y Arriaga identifies the Pontificate of Pope Paul VI as a turning point, marking the beginning of a new era in which the Church has become increasingly influenced by secular and Masonic ideologies.

The book highlights the rise of charismatic movements, such as the Cursillo and Christian Family Movement, which the author sees as a departure from traditional Catholic spirituality and a threat to institutional authority.

Saenz y Arriaga also critiques the theological views of Hans Kung and Jacob Maritain, whom he regards as representative of the liberal and modernist tendencies within the Church.

The New Montinian Church was widely read and discussed within traditionalist Catholic circles, particularly among those who opposed the reforms introduced by Vatican II. The book’s publication led to Fr. Saenz y Arriaga’s excommunication in 1972, as he was deemed to be promoting sedevacantism (the belief that the papal throne is vacant due to heresy or apostasy).

Despite this, the book remains an influential work within traditionalist Catholicism, offering a comprehensive critique of Vatican II’s changes and their perceived consequences for the Church. Its themes and arguments continue to be debated among Catholics who question the Council’s reforms and seek to preserve traditional Catholic teachings and practices.